There's Nothing Simple About Lying

We're just two friends who are incredibly obsessed with Pretty Little Liars and wanted a place where we could post our favorite pictures, quotes, and theories about what goes on in Rosewood.

Our theories are constantly changing, and just because we put it here, doesn't mean we totally believe it. We just love obsessing over every detail and overthinking everything that happens.

Feel free to message us or to follow our personal blogs!
Emily: goldiegirlem.tumblr.com
Jenna: abeautifulmess-19.tumblr.com

Home
THEORIES
Aria
Spencer
Hanna
Emily
Alison
Mona
Jenna
Melissa
Garrett
Jason
Toby
Caleb
Ezra
Wren
Maya
Lucas
Noel
Paige
CeCe
Byron
Ella
Hastings
Red Coat / Head A
Who is the A Team?
Who Killed Alison?
Marlene King's Tweets
Archive
Subscribe (RSS)
Ask Us Anything... If You Dare
Submit For Yourself
Random post

Catching Elephant is a theme by Andy Taylor

 

garbage-pail-cousin asked
Yeah, in the books there were a handful of people that knew. I think Jenna, Wilden, and Melissa for sure. I can't remember who else.

If all of these people know (on the show - the book is different enough), I want to know how the girls HAVEN’T found out with all the snooping they do…

garbage-pail-cousin asked
I think it'd be really unrealistic if Alison has been in Ravenswood. In what world does a neighboring town not know about and recognize a missing, then later found murdered blonde girl? There is no way that she could be out and about in Ravenswood without someone saying, "Aren't you Alison DiLaurentis?"

I totally agree! But I think that if Alison has a twin at all I’m going to think that there was no way it was plausible. SOMEONE would know. SOMEONE would figure something out. There’s no way that an entire town could be duped like that…

nevergrowingupinwonderland asked
I have a feeling if they go with the twin theory that Alison or whatever twin is alive has been hiding out at Ravenwood this whole time..

Yeah.. I totally agree. Personally I think it’s a cop out, but what do you think?

lovepll1234 asked
The question you asked towards the person underneath the vial. I think it's Tess from ravenswood or one of the little girl from 2x12 and 3x13. She's grown up now and is attending a funeral of a family member.

Wow. Great ideas!! Thanks!

wonderfulandlovely asked
To me, the Veiled Girl looks like Aria, Kate or the woman Byron had an affair with, I can't remember her name., but I have seriously given up on trying identify people on this show haha.

LOVE the idea that it is Kate or Meredith! We see Aria without a veil, so we don’t think it’s her… But what a twist Kate or Meredith would be! Thanks!

Who is the veiled griever?

If it’s Jason’s funeral, then it could be Mrs. DiLaurentis. If it’s CeCe’s funeral, it could be her mother or her sister. If it’s a funeral for that body in the woods, then it is possibly someone we don’t know…

What do you think?

The Veiled Griever

undercoverinrosewood:

prettylittlehearts3:

image

The Veiled Griever is one of the alias in s4. This is anonymous character which will first appear in the first episode of the summer premier in the funeral. Brace yourself guys cause the red coat, queen of hearts, killer and every other suspense wasn’t enough- More are coming!

It’ll probably be “Alison” again. 

Inbox us with your most burning question! We want to research/brainstorm what you want to know!

jangonzalez asked
so in the books spencer suffers from rage induced black outs. remember how her and alison argued the day she alison dissapeared? what if spencer killed her and just dosent remember because she blacked out. i just feel like spencer has alot more to do with what happened that night than what we know of so far

You bring up a great point; however, I think that the writers put this part in the book into the show differently. Remember how Emily went to therapy with Dr. Sullivan and remembered (or so she thought she remembered) hitting Alison with a shovel? I think that having Spencer also blacking out events would be a little bit too much.

pretttylittletheories: Marlene Kings SPOILER of Season 4! (from the Katie Couric 200k challenge!) This is so crazy… But because it is a flashback, this is before Jenna moves in and puts the snow globes on the shelves. So Jenna’s room used to be Toby’s room? Why did he have to change rooms when his dad married Jenna’s mom? What do you think Toby and Alison are talking about?

pretttylittletheories:

Marlene Kings SPOILER of Season 4!
(from the Katie Couric 200k challenge!)

This is so crazy… But because it is a flashback, this is before Jenna moves in and puts the snow globes on the shelves. So Jenna’s room used to be Toby’s room? Why did he have to change rooms when his dad married Jenna’s mom?

What do you think Toby and Alison are talking about?